In Seasons 1 and 2 of The Sopranos, the biggest threat to Tony Soprano’s continued hold on his mafia enterprise wasn’t the feds or rival bosses. It was his mother, Livia Soprano, masterfully played by veteran stage and screen actress Nancy Marchand. Tony and Livia’s fraught (to say the least) relationship provided much of the emotional and psychological backbone of the first two seasons, as Tony worked in therapy to unravel the psychic hold his mother had on him. Marchand brilliantly embodied one of the most monstrous mothers in television history, effortlessly leaning on Tony’s guilt and sense of familial duty to manipulate him for her own ends.
It was a performance that did its job almost too well, as frequent trips to Livia’s world could be both darkly funny and deeply enraging to watch. Sadly, Livia’s time tormenting Tony (at least on this earthly plane) was cut tragically short, when Marchand passed away from cancer after Season 2. This heartbreaking off-screen turn forced creator David Chase and the writers to drastically alter the trajectory of Season 3, in which Livia was originally going to play a major role. But while Marchand’s passing is undeniably tragic, having to remove Livia from the story may have actually benefited the series in the long run.
‘The Sopranos’ Future Plans for Livia
When The Sopranos aired its first season, Chase was convinced it wouldn’t get another one. He originally planned for Tony to kill his mother after she influenced his Uncle Junior (Dominic Chianese) to have him killed, but he wasn’t able to go through with it. Marchand was so good in her role that Chase decided to leave the character alive, just in case the show got renewed. Of course, it did, and Livia’s role in Season 2 was expanded to keep her character involved. Marchand was sick with lung cancer and emphysema during the filming of Season 2, but the production accommodated her, shooting scenes with her either in bed or sitting down.
In Season 3, Livia was initially going to have to testify against Tony in a RICO trial (a racketeering charge that allows authorities to go after mob bosses), requiring Tony to get back into her good graces in order to stay out of jail. This was set up in Season 2, when Tony gives Livia a pair of stolen airline tickets to try to get her to fly out west to stay with her sister. While concrete evidence against Tony to press RICO charges was scarce, the stolen tickets were the FBI’s ace in the hole.
This whole plotline had to be scrapped when Marchand passed away before the trial scenes could be filmed. Rather than concoct some strange workaround to keep the character alive but out of the picture, Chase and the writers decided to confront Marchand’s death head-on by having Livia die as well. In Season 3’s second episode, “Proshai, Livushka,” Livia and Tony have one last back-and-forth as Tony tries to convince her to keep her mouth shut about the stolen tickets, using a crude form of CGI deepfake that is, to put it mildly, rather unconvincing. While many were dismayed by the special effects, Chase later said in an interview that he meant it as a way to honor Marchand’s work, giving her character one last onscreen appearance.
Related
One Line in ‘The Sopranos’ Season 2 Confirms What We All Assumed About the Finale
Chrissy warned Tony about his ultimate fate in the season finale years before it happened.
Why Livia’s Death May Have Helped the Series
To be perfectly clear, this is not to say that Marchand’s passing was in any way a good thing, or that the benefit the series gained from the character’s death is a reflection of the actor. Marchand did a wonderful job as Livia, the kind of final role any actor would love to have, and her dedication to her work carried through until the very end. But as far as the character goes, having Livia die early in Season 3 changed The Sopranos’ continuing storyline for the better.
While Livia and Tony’s relationship provided fertile dramatic ground in the first season, it’s the kind of dynamic that likely wouldn’t work in the long-term. The scenes with Livia often followed a familiar pattern, where the character would lay thick layers of guilt on whoever was around, often breaking down into crocodile tears while lamenting her lot in life. This was already starting to feel a bit repetitive by Season 2, and the corroded nature of Livia’s humanity didn’t really give the character any other direction to go. It’s likely that, had Marchand lived to continue the planned story, the character’s continued presence would have worn thin before too long.
Related
David Lynch’s Influence Even Extended to ‘The Sopranos’
David Lynch’s unique vision for ‘Twin Peaks’ influenced HBO’s hit mob drama ‘The Sopranos.’
It’s highly unlikely that Livia’s arc in the series would have seen her taking accountability for her actions and trying to mend her relationships, which would have been completely out of character and might have felt forced. Tony had already cut ties with her at the end of Season 1, which didn’t leave much room for their dynamic to go any lower. By having the character die in Season 3, Tony is forced to confront his unresolved feelings of anger, guilt, and grief surrounding his relationship with his mother and her sudden passing, which served to add greater depth to his emotional arc. Plus, just because Livia left the living world didn’t mean she stopped tormenting Tony, as the specter of her presence (maybe literally, in The Sopranos’ surprisingly spooky world) continued to have an influence on him.
Nancy Marchand gave a terrific performance on The Sopranos, a figure who was equal parts exasperating and pitiful, and her relationship with Tony provided a strong emotional foundation for the series. But while the world of television lost a legend with her passing, forcing the series to navigate her character’s loss inadvertently added new layers to the show’s rich and complex family tapestry. It’s impossible to know what the series would have done with her character going forward, or if she would have stuck around for the whole series, but her passing served to enrich the complex, deeply human character at the center. Just another reason why The Sopranos remains one of the greatest series of all time.
